8 Best Pizza Places in Aruba: Get the Island’s Top Slices

Aruba has no shortage of incredible dining options, but if you’re craving the best pizza in Aruba, you’re in luck. From casual local spots to sit-down restaurants in Palm Beach and Eagle Beach, this guide highlights the top pizza places in Aruba worth adding to your itinerary.

We’ll touch on family-friendly pizza restaurants Aruba visitors love and late-night delivery options. These are the best pizza places in Aruba. Try one, or try them all and let us know your favorite!

Disclosure: Some of the links below may be affiliate links. At no additional cost to you, we may earn a small commission if you make a purchase.

Amore Mio Pizzeria Napoletana

Located right in the heart of Palm Beach, Amore Mio Pizzeria Napoletana brings true Neapolitan craftsmanship to Aruba. Their pizzas are baked in an authentic wood-fired oven, producing a lightly blistered crust with a soft, chewy center… exactly the way Naples intended. Guests consistently call out the Capricciosa as one of the top pizzas on the island, thanks to its balance of artichokes, ham, and mushrooms.

Amore Mio, part of the Gianni’s Group, offers both indoor and outdoor seating, creating the perfect people-watching spot along the Palm Beach strip. Service is friendly, the atmosphere is relaxed, and their menu includes salads, pasta, and gluten-free options. They also offer takeout and participate in local delivery platforms, making it convenient whether you’re dining out or enjoying pizza back at your resort.

• Address: J.E. Irausquin Blvd 348, Palm Beach – across from Hilton
• Phone: +297 586-2101
• Daily Hours: 7am – 12am; Delivery Service: 11am – 9:30pm

Casa Tua Pizzeria

Casa Tua Pizzeria, with locations in Palm Beach and downtown Oranjestad, is known for its thin, crispy crust and dough made fresh every single day. This family-friendly Italian restaurant blends warm hospitality with consistently great pizza. It’s the kind that feels light, fresh, and easy to enjoy after a day at the beach. Diners often rave about the crust specifically, praising its perfect balance between crispness and softness.

Casa Tua offers open-air seating in the center of Palm Beach, making it a fun, lively place for couples and families. Although they’re primarily dine-in, service is fast and takeout is always an option. With classic Italian dishes rounding out the menu, it’s an excellent choice for groups that want more than just pizza.

• Address: J.E. Irausquin Blvd 370, Arawak Garden, Palm Beach
• Phone: +297 586-8470
• Daily Hours: 5pm – 11pm

• Address: Renaissance Market Place, Suite 27, Lloyd G. Smith Blvd 9, Oranjestad
• Phone: +297 583-1990
• Daily Hours: 8am – 11pm

Urataka Center

If you’re looking for a favorite local institution, head inland to Urataka Center in Santa Cruz. This rustic, open-air bar-restaurant is famous for its creative, hearty pizzas with Aruban flair. Their “Super Burger Pizza” and “Pizza Paranda” have cult followings as they’re topped generously and overflowing with bold flavors you won’t find elsewhere on the island.

Urataka Center has a laid-back, community feel where you’ll instantly feel at home. It’s casual, affordable, and known for large portions. Dine-in is the norm here, and the atmosphere is all part of the experience, but they also offer pizza delivery for those staying farther out. If you want a slice of true local Aruba, Urataka is a must-visit.

• Address: Urataka 12-A, Oranjestad
• Phone: +297 585-5212
• Hours: Monday 10am – 11pm, Tuesday – Sunday 11am – 11pm

Pizza Napoli

A favorite along the Palm Beach strip, Pizza Napoli serves wood-fired pies with beautifully crisp edges and high-quality toppings. Though their name suggests Naples tradition, their style leans slightly more Roman: thinner, crispier, and perfect if you prefer a lighter, crunchier crust. Customers frequently praise the simplicity and freshness of their ingredients, especially classic margarita lovers.

Pizza Napoli is casual, quick, and reliable, ideal for a relaxed dine-in experience or a grab-and-go pizza to bring back to your hotel. They also offer delivery, which makes them a go-to option if you’re staying in Palm Beach but want an easy dinner without the wait of a full restaurant meal.

• Address: J.E. Irausquin Blvd 382, Palm Beach – inside Paseo Herencia Mall
• Phone: +297 748-6928
• Daily Hours: 11am – 1am

Pizza Italia

In Oranjestad, Pizza Italia is a small, authentic spot recognized for its genuine Italian flavors. The owner is from Italy, and that authenticity shows in the dough, sauce, and traditional brick-oven baking method. It’s not flashy or polished. It’s simply excellent pizza with a homemade feel. Many visitors discover it by word of mouth and then return year after year. (You could be one of them!)

Pizza Italia offers dine-in and takeout, and while it’s smaller than the high-rise restaurants, the quality speaks for itself. If you’re exploring Oranjestad or want something tucked away from the resort areas, this is a fantastic stop.

• Address: Caya Ernesto Petronia 67B, Oranjestad
• Phone: +297 742-7817
• Hours: 4pm – 11pm Wednesday – Monday (Closed Tuesdays)

North End Pub & Grill

While primarily a pub, North End Pub & Grill has earned a reputation for serving unexpectedly great pizza in a fun, casual environment. It’s the kind of place where the pizza comes hot, hearty, and satisfying, perfect alongside a cold beer. Many repeat customers recommend it as one of the best low-key pizza spots near the Marriott Surf Club and High-Rise hotels.

North End is best for dine-in, especially if you’re looking to escape the tourist-heavy restaurants and enjoy something more local. It’s a great option for a laid-back night with good food and drinks.

• Location: J.E. Irausquin Blvd 384-A, Lok 8
• Phone: +297 748-3917
• Daily Hours: 8am – 12am

Papia Mia Restaurant Aruba

For a lively night out with great pizza, Papia Mia offers one of the most energetic dining experiences in Palm Beach. Their handcrafted pizzas are backed by a menu inspired by local flavors with bold sauces, fresh ingredients, and fun twists that feel distinctly Aruban. The atmosphere is upbeat, where you can often hear the music from next door, Kalibra Bar, and a steady flow of cocktails.

Papia Mia is best enjoyed dine-in, thanks to its overall vibe. Their pizza quality, combined with the experience, makes it a great choice if you want more than a meal… you want a night out.

• Address: Palm Beach 55, South Beach Centre
• Phone: +297 280-0408
• Hours: 11am – 11pm Monday – Thursday, 11am – 1am Friday – Saturday, 11am – 12am Sunday

Pizzería Aruba Loves You

A new favorite right on the strip, Aruba Loves You Pizzabar is the place to go when you want great pizza fast, especially if you want it delivered. This casual pizzeria-bar hybrid serves some of the best late-night pizza in Aruba, and you’ll love the convenience and consistently good pies. If you’re staying at a Palm Beach resort and want an easy dinner after a day in the sun, this is one of the most reliable delivery options.

They also offer dine-in and takeout, but for pizza delivery in Aruba, they really shine. You’ll repeatedly hear praise of their quick service and flavorful pizzas, making them a top choice for hotel guests.

• Location: Located at Paseo Herencia Mall in Palm Beach – next to Tommy Hilfiger
• Phone: +297 746-3387
• Hours: 6pm – 10pm Monday, 6pm – 10:30pm Tuesday – Sunday